Barbara Crabb

From Judgepedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Barbara Crabb
Barb Crabb.jpg
Current Court Information:
United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin
Title:   Senior Judge
Position:   Seat #2
Service:
Appointed by:   Jimmy Carter
Active:   11/2/1979 - 3/24/2010
Chief:   1980 - 1996 ; 2001 - 2010
Senior:   3/24/2010 - Present
Preceded by:   92 Stat. 1629
Succeeded by:   William Conley
Past post:   U.S. Magistrate
Past term:   1971 - 1979
Personal History
Born:   1939
Hometown:   Green Bay, WI
Undergraduate:   U. of Wisconsin, Madison, B.A., 1960
Law School:   U. of Wisconsin Law School, LL.B., 1962



Barbara Brandriff Crabb is a federal district court judge in the United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin. She joined the court in 1979 after being nominated by President Jimmy Carter. She served the court as chief judge from 1980-1996. On December 31, 2009, Crabb assumed senior status.[1][2]

Early life and education

Born in Green Bay, Crabb graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Madison with her bachelor's degree in 1960 and her Law degree in 1962.

Professional career

After graduation from law school, Crabb entered into private practice in Madison from 1962 to 1968 then from 1968 to 1971 Crabb worked as a Research assistant for professor George Bunn at the University of Wisconsin Law School from 1968-1969 and as a Research assistant for the American Bar Association's Project on Minimum Standards of Criminal Justice from 1970 to 1971.[2]

Judicial career

Western District of Wisconsin

Crabb was recommended by former Senator Wiliam Proxmire to be nominated by President Jimmy Carter on July 21, 1979, to a new seat created by 92 Stat. 1629. Crabb was confirmed by the Senate on October 31, 1979, and received her commission for the Western District of Wisconsin on November 2, 1979. Crabb served as the chief judge from 1980 to 1996. Crabb also served as U.S. Magistrate judge for the Western District of Wisconsin from 1971 to 1979.[2]

Unexpected Senior Status announcement

On March 20, 2009, Judge Crabb unexpectedly announced her intention to take on senior status.

In her release issued to the Wisconsin media, Crabb stated:

"Over the past several years, this court’s ever-expanding and increasingly complex caseload has required extraordinary efforts from all of the judges and court staff in order to provide the prompt resolution of cases that all litigants have a right to expect. All indicators suggest that this trend will continue unabated.

"One solution would be to ask Congress to authorize a third judgeship for this court, but this would be a time-consuming and expensive proposition. A more cost-effective and immediate solution would be for me to take senior status. This would allow me to continue my work for the court at a less frenetic pace while opening a full-time position for another federal judge. Given the nation’s current economic straits and the immediate needs of this court, I have decided after considerable reflection that this is the best course for all concerned. Therefore, I have written President Obama to report my intention to take senior status as soon as my successor can be appointed."[3]

Notable cases

National Day of Prayer challenge (2010)

  United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin
     *Freedom from Religion Foundation, Inc., v. President Barack Obama and White House Press Secretary Robert L. Gibbs 3:08-cv-00588-bbc
Judge Crabb ruled on April 15, 2010 that the "National Day of Prayer," which was established by Congress in 1952, was unconstitutional. The Madison, Wisconsin based Freedom from Religion Foundation filed the lawsuit against both the Obama and Bush administrations in order to block the Presidents from making the customary annual proclamation of the event. The decision will not affect President Barack Obama's decision to make a proclamation for the 2010 National Day of Prayer.

The United States Department of Justice, which represented the defendants, will review the ruling before pursuing an appeal to the Chicago-based Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals.[4]

Members of the Congressional Prayer Caucus have been critical of Judge Crabb's ruling and planned a news conference for April 21, 2010 to denounce her ruling. The injunction, however, does not take effect until the legal counsel representing the White House have exhausted all their appeals, a process which could take years.[5]

The U.S. Department of Justice announced on April 22, 2010, that they will plan to appeal the case to the Seventh Circuit.[6]


Judicial free speech rights (2009)

  United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin
     *Honorable John Siefert, v. James C. Alexander, et al. 3:08-cv-126
Judge Crabb ruled in a case in which Milwaukee County Circuit Court judge John Siefert had sought the right to join the Democratic party, endorse then Presidential candidate Barack Obama, and personally solicit campaign contributions.[7]. Each of these activities was prohibited by the Wisconsin Code of Judicial Conduct.

In March of 2008, Siefert brought suit in the United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin against the current sitting members of the Wisconsin Judicial Commission, arguing that the restrictions violated his First Amendment free speech rights.[7]

On February 18, 2009, Judge Crabb ruled based on a precedent established in Republican Party of Minnesota v. White, stating that the Wisconsin Judicial Commission's stance on the code of judicial conduct restricts speech in such a way as to violate the first amendment. This ruling could help pave the way for partisan judicial elections in Wisconsin.[7]


See also

External links

References

Federal judicial offices
Preceded by:
NA-New Seat
Western District of Wisconsin
1979–2010
Seat #2
Succeeded by:
William Conley