Do you have a photo that could go here? Submit it for this profile by emailing us!
|Current Court Information:|
|United States District Court for the Southern District of New York|
|Station:||New York, NY|
|Appointed by:||Ronald Reagan|
|Active:||09/20/1983 - 12/30/1996|
|Senior:||12/31/1996 - Present|
|Preceded by:||Lloyd MacMahon|
|Succeeded by:||Colleen McMahon|
|Hometown:||New York, NY|
|Undergraduate:||Manhattan College, B.B.A., 1951|
|Law School:||Fordham U. Law, LL.B., 1954|
|Military service:||U.S. Army 1954 - 1956|
John Fontaine Keenan is a federal judge for the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. He joined the court in 1983 after being nominated by President Ronald Reagan. He is serving on senior status.
Early life and education
Keenan served in the United States Army from 1954 to 1956. He was Assistant District Attorney for New York County, New York from 1956 to 1976. During that time, Judge Keenan was in charge of New York County's Supreme Court Bureau from 1968-1969, and later in charge of the Homicide Bureau from 1970 to 1973.
Judge Keenan served as Chief Assistant District Attorney of Queens County New York in 1973, and then Assistant District Attorney in charge of trials for New York County in 1974. Thereafter, he was appointed to serve as Chief Assistant District Attorney for New York County from 1974 to 1976. As New York State Deputy Attorney General, Keenan served as a Special Prosecutor in charge of the Anti-Corruption Division from 1976 to 1979.
From 1979 to 1982, he was Chairman and President of the New York City Off-Track Betting Corporation. Immediately prior to his appointment as a federal judge, Keenan was the Criminal Justice Coordinator for New York City from 1982 to 1983.
Southern District of New York
On the recommendation of U.S. Senator Al D'Amato, Keenan was nominated to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York by President Ronald Reagan on September 13, 1983 to a seat vacated by Lloyd MacMahon. Keenan was confirmed by the Senate on September 20, 1983 on a Senate vote and received commission on September 20, 1983. Keenan assumed senior status on December 31, 1996.
Merck's Fosamax allegedly causes disability (2013)United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (Scheinberg v. Merck & Co, Inc., No. 08 Civ. 4119(JFK))
Judge Keenan presided over a 'mass action' or multi-district litigation suit involving the osteoporosis drug Fosamax, manufactured by Merck & Co. Over 900 plaintiffs have filed suit against Merck in federal and state court, alleging generally that the use of their drug Fosamax can cause a condition known as osteonecrosis, which destroys the jaw, and that Merck failed to give proper warnings of this risk. Many of these actions have been consolidated in the case before Judge Keenan.
The judge also presided over individual actions before the cases were consolidated. On September 8, 2009, Judge Keenan gave the jury more time to deliberate after they were deadlocked after one of the trials. He dismissed another in November of 2009. On January 29, 2010, he refused to dismiss another and ordered that it will go to trial. Thus far, Merck has won two of three cases that have gone to trial so far, not counting the one which was dismissed.In February of 2011, Keenan issued an order saying he needs to hear two more bellwether (test) cases before deciding on whether to send the cases that remain back to the original courts they were filed in. The judge stated that he needs to hear a case involving a person taking the drug before Merck updated its label in July of 2005 to reflect the risk of osteonecrosis, and where that person claims they developed problems with their jaw after the change. The other case the judge said he needs to hear first is one involving a person who used the drug after the label change and developed the jaw problems. On February 5, 2013, a jury ruled against Merck, awarding $285,000 to plaintiff Rhonda Scheinberg. July 1, 2013, Judge Keenan denied a request by Merck to remove the $285,000 payment.
- Judge Keenan's biography at the Federal Judicial Center
- List of Article III judges of the Southern District of New York
- Courthouse News Service, "Iranian bomb plotter gets 25 years in prison," May 30, 2013
- Judge John Keenan's biography at the Federal Judicial Center
- The Wall Street Journal: Law Blog, "Judge wants more 'bellwether' trials in litigation over Merck's Fosamax," February 7, 2011
- Alibaba.com, "Judge refuses to dismiss Fosamax case, sets trial," January 31, 2010
- Bloomberg News, "Merck jury told to keep deliberating in Fosamax case," September 8, 2009
- Reuters, "Merck hit with $285,000 verdict in Fosamax trial," February 5, 2013
- Law360, "Merck Can't Duck Jury Award In Fosamax Bellwether Suit," July 1, 2013
|Federal judicial offices|
|Southern District of New York
Chief Judge: Loretta Preska • Kevin Castel • Paul Crotty • George Daniels • Paul Gardephe • Kenneth Karas • John Koeltl • Colleen McMahon • William Pauley • Cathy Seibel • Richard Sullivan • Laura Swain • Andrew L. Carter, Jr. • Nelson S. Roman • Analisa Torres • J. Paul Oetken • Vincent L. Briccetti • Paul A. Engelmayer • Alison J. Nathan • Edgardo Ramos • Katherine Forrest • Jesse Furman • Ronnie Abrams • Lorna Schofield • Katherine Failla • Valerie Caproni • Vernon Broderick • Gregory Howard Woods
Victor Marrero • Kimba Wood • Deborah Batts • Richard Berman • Naomi Buchwald • Robert Lee Carter • Miriam Goldman Cedarbaum • Denise Cote • Thomas Griesa • Charles Haight • Alvin Hellerstein • Lewis Kaplan • John Keenan • Peter Leisure • Lawrence McKenna • Richard Owen • Robert Patterson • Jed Rakoff • Leonard Sand • Shira Scheindlin • Louis Stanton • Sidney Stein • Robert Sweet • Kevin Duffy • Gerard Goettel •
|Magistrate judges||Henry Pitman • Michael Dolinger • Ronald Ellis • Kevin Fox • James Francis • Debra Freeman • Martin Goldberg • Gabriel Gorenstein • Frank Maas • Andrew Peck • Lisa Smith • Paul Davison • James L. Cott • Sarah Netburn • Judith C. McCarthy •|
|Former Article III judges||
Michael Mukasey • Morris Lasker • Harold Baer • Denny Chin • William Conner • Richard Holwell • Barbara Jones • Shirley Kram • Gerard Lynch • Stephen Robinson • John Sprizzo • William Peter Van Ness • Samuel Rossiter Betts • Samuel Blatchford • Sonia Sotomayor • William Gardner Choate • Pierre Leval • Wilfred Feinberg • John Walker • Barrington Parker • Lawrence Pierce • Addison Brown • George Bethune Adams • George Chandler Holt • Charles Merrill Hough • Learned Hand • Julius Marshuetz Mayer • Augustus Noble Hand • John Clark Knox • Martin Thomas Manton • William Bondy • Henry Warren Goddard • Francis Asbury Winslow • Frank Joseph Coleman • Thomas Day Thacher • Alfred Conkling Coxe, Jr. • John Munro Woolsey • George Murray Hulbert • John William Clancy • Vincent Leibell • Samuel Mandelbaum • Edward Conger • Robert Porter Patterson, Sr. • Charles Metzner • Arnold Bauman • Alexander Bicks • Dudley Bonsal • Charles Brieant • John Bright • Vincent Broderick • Frederick Bryan • Francis Caffey • John Cannella • Richard Casey • John Cashin • Kenneth Conboy • Irving Cooper • Thomas Croake • Richard Daronco • Archie Dawson • Edward Dimock • David Edelstein • Marvin Frankel • Louis Freeh • Lee Gagliardi • Murray Gurfein • William Herlands • Irving Kaufman • Samuel Kaufman • Percy Knapp • Richard Levet • Mary Lowe • Lloyd MacMahon • Walter Mansfield • John McGohey • Edward McLean • Harold Medina • Constance Motley • Thomas Murphy • Gregory Noonan • Edmund Palmieri • Milton Pollack • Simon Rifkind • Sylvester Ryan • Allen Schwartz • Abraham Sofaer • Charles Stewart • Sidney Sugarman • Charles Tenney • Harold Tyler • Lawrence Walsh • Robert Ward • Edward Weinfeld • Henry Werker • Inzer Wyatt • John S. Martin • John S. Martin, Jr. •
|Former Chief judges||
Kimba Wood • Andrew Peck • Lisa Smith • John Clark Knox • William Bondy • John William Clancy • Charles Brieant • David Edelstein • Lloyd MacMahon • Constance Motley • Sylvester Ryan • Sidney Sugarman •