Stoughton Trailers, Inc. v. Labor & Industry Review Commission (2007)

From Judgepedia

Jump to: navigation, search
Wisconsin Supreme Court
Sitting justices
Shirley Abrahamson
Ann Walsh Bradley
N. Patrick Crooks
Michael Gableman
David Prosser
Patience Roggensack
Annette Ziegler
Former justices
Notable rulings
2009 challengers
Randy Koschnick
Wisconsin on Judgepedia
Stoughton Trailers, Inc. v. Labor & Industry Review Commission (2007)


  • Justice Louis Butler authored the majority opinion, which concluded, over vigorous dissent, that Wisconsin employers were required to extend "clemency" to employees who were absent from work for medical reasons, even where many of the absences are unrelated to medical reasons. In doing so, the Majority effectively eviscerates any employer attendance requirements. According to the dissent, authored by David T. Prosser, the Majority's rule "requires an employer to suspend its attendance requirements even if an employee fails to submit medical documentation confirming that his absence was disability related."